Smart Proof
  •   Home   Contact Us   Quick Tour    Help    FAQ   Log out
Contact



Info:   Any queries pertaining to the proofs should be written as a comment in the proof. Any queries received via the ‘Contact Us’ button could delay article publication.
Submit
Mail Preview
Send
 Edit  Clean View  PDF  Track PDF This article preview for your reference
  •   Submit
  •   User Guide
  •   Contact Us

1. How would you rate your experience of the online proofing tool?

2. What would have improved your experience with the proofing tool?

3. How useful did you find the instructions / help for using the tool?

4. How easy was it to use the tool to respond to the Author Queries?

            
Add Author Query

File not found
Edit Author Query
File not found
Figure Edit


Save Cancel

  •     
    Navigation
    Navigation
  •     
    Author Queries
    Author Query
  • Footnote
  •     
    Equations
  •     
    Tables
  •     
    Figures
  •     
    References
  •     
    Comments
  •     
    CE Tools

    Consistency Checker

    PROCEED









    Affiliation Citations

    References Citations

    PROCEED

    Editing Choice

    PROCEED

    References Sort

    PROCEED


  •     
    Attachments
  •     
    Edit Summary
  •     
    Approve Article

    Please confirm you have reviewed this proof, are satisfied with your changes, and understand you will not be able to make additional corrections once you click on the Approve/Submit button. If you have any additional notes for the Production Team please leave them in the white box below.




    Submit

  • Reference
    Please set the cursor where you want to place the reference citation and then click OK.
    Please set the cursor where you want to place the reference citation and then click OK.
    Info:   The references listed below do not have a corresponding in-text citation; please add a text citation for these missing references to then enable a view of the entire reference list for further citation insertion.
    Select Reference
    • Plain Text
    • DOI
    • PubMed

    Range
    MissingRef  Position 
    Type 

    Plain

    DOI

    PubMed

    Insert Validate
    Please add reference details by clicking the ‘Add Reference’ button below.



    Info:   New reference will be added; subsequent references and citations will be renumbered automatically.
    Info:   As reference citation order is not sequential in this article, please select the required order (“position”) to insert the new reference. New reference will be added; subsequent references and citations will be renumbered automatically.
  • Reference

    Do you want to update this reference?


    Validate Update Check URL Cancel




    Caution:   Remember to update the spelling in the respective in-text citation(s) if you change the author’s name spelling in the reference list.
  • Reference

    Do you want to delete this reference?


    Delete Cancel




    Note:   Once you delete the reference from the reference list, respective citation will be deleted from the article.
  •     
    Link
    Cancel Check URL UnLink URL Insert
  •     
    Keywords
    Drag and drop to re-order Sort alphabetically

    Keywords Punctuation
      Add Keyword
    •     
      Abbreviations
      Drag and drop to re-order Sort alphabetically

      Keywords Punctuation
        Add Abbreviations
      •     
        Funding Information
      •     




      •     




      •     




      •     
        Notes on Acknowledgement






      •     
        Teaser






      •     
        Notes on Contributor






      •     
        Table Footnote
      •     
        Alternative Text
      • Affliation
        Please set the cursor where you want to place the Affliation citation and then click OK.

        Add new Affliation


        Add Cancel
      • Affliation

        Do you want Delete this affliation ?


        Delete Cancel
      • Affliation
        Select Affiliation
        Insert

      • Affliation
        Select Delete Citation
        Delete

      • EndNote
        Select EndNote
        Insert

      • Footnote Citation
        Select Footnote
        Insert

      • Table footnote

        Label

        Add new Footnote


        Add Cancel
      • Add Footnote
        Info:   Please set the cursor where you want to place the footnote citation and then click OK.

        Add new Footnote


        Add Cancel
      • Footnote

        Delete Footnote


        Delete Cancel
      • ORCID

        Enter ORCID value



        Add Cancel
      • Special Instruction













      • ORCID

        Edit ORCID value



        Update Cancel
      • Author Grou

            *




          https://orcid.org/
          Click here to validate orcid





          Note: To use the Ext-Link option, please select email text and click the Ext-Link option.

          Link Affiliation

            Link Correspondence

              The form field must be closed before editing can resume.
            • Footnote
              Add New Footnote








                Link Author
                  The form field must be closed before editing can resume.
                • Corresponding Author







                    Note: To use the Ext-Link option, please select email text and click the Ext-Link option.

                    Link Author
                    •     
                      PDF Comments
                    • Affiliation
                      Drag and drop to re-order
                      Add New Affiliation

                        Drag and drop to re-order

                          Link Author
                            The form field must be closed before editing can resume.
                          →

                          We noticed that collaborators(s) still need to confirm the completion of the proof review. If you want to submit the proof now, you should revoke their access. Any changes already made by the collaborator(s) will be retained.

                          Revoke collaborator(s) access and submit the proof now
                          Wait for collaborator(s) to confirm the completion of the proof review
                          Submit
                          Submit
                          Send Reminder & Hold Submission
                          Hold Submission

                          Special Character

                          For more special characters Click here.

                          Latex Editor




                          Note: Please do not enter any comments or instructions in the LaTeX coding box below. Use it for editing equations.

                          Reference


                          Preview Save


                          Repost Article

                          Do you want repost the article?


                          We couldn't locate an exact match in CrossRef and PubMed. Please review the closest match below to determine if it should be replaced.

                          Supplementary Attachment
                          Cancel Save

                          ePub Date



                          Reference Edit

                          Preview Save


                          If you wish to Approve the article, please click on one of the two options.


                          Figure
                          Drag & drop image here or choose image
                          Save Cancel

                          Preview

                          Cancel Proceed
                          Meta Data

                          Close
                          ×

                          Please choose


                          Equ-(1) Equ-(1a)

                          Copyright © 2026 KnowledgeWorks Global Ltd, All rights reserved. |